OSRS Card Exchange
← All quests

Misthalin Mystery

NoviceFree-to-playShort

OSRS TCG Misthalin Mystery — Old School RuneScape quest card mapping

Start: talk to Abigale.

A woman cries as a man lays dying, desperately they beg you to stop a cryptic killer before their friends suffer a similar fate.

Misthalin Mystery is a free-to-play Old School RuneScape quest rated Novice. The OSRS TCG Misthalin Mystery card list covers 3 of the items and monsters involved, including Bucket, Tinderbox and Knife. This page pairs the quest with those cards and with the open player trades for them; the OSRS Wiki remains the authority on requirements and the walkthrough itself.

Full quest guide on the OSRS Wiki →

Beta: quest cards are matched to the best of our current knowledge and may include some mismatches — we're still working through the data. If something doesn't look right, please submit feedback.

The quest and minigame card relationships on this page are maintained by OSRS Card Exchange. Whether a related item or monster currently appears as a card, and its displayed OSRS TCG rarity, are legacy compatibility fields derived from the referenced OSRS TCG catalogue snapshot. OSRS Card Exchange is independently operated and is not affiliated with or endorsed by OSRS TCG or its developers. View OSRS TCG attribution and licence information.

Required items & monsters

Items you need to bring and the monsters you'll fight, paired with their OSRS TCG cards. See the wiki for the full requirement list.

Bucket

Bucket

Resource

It's a wooden bucket.

2 gpCommon

Tinderbox

Tinderbox

Resource

Useful for lighting a fire.

1 gpCommon

Knife

Knife

Resource

A dangerous looking knife.

6 gpCommon

Walkthrough overview

A brief summary of the quest, noting where each card is used. The OSRS Wiki has the full, authoritative walkthrough.

  1. 1

    Talk to Abigale south-east of Lumbridge Swamp and take the rowboat to the island. Pick up a bucket by the fountain, fill it at the rainwater barrel and search the barrel for the manor key.

    • Bucket
  2. 2

    Enter the manor and pick up the knife. After the note appears, use the knife on the mountain-and-river painting and search it to find the ruby key.

    • Knife
    • Tinderbox
  3. 3

    Climb the wall and go north; after Lacey is killed, read the killer's note and solve the piano riddle in the north-eastern room.

  4. 4

    Re-enter through the damaged east wall and open the emerald door. Read the third note and solve the fireplace riddle in the eastern room.

    • Knife
  5. 5

    Confront the Killer in the western room; push the mirror to reflect his thrown knives back at him until he is defeated to finish the quest.

Open exchanges for these cards

Loading open exchanges…

OSRS TCG Misthalin Mystery — frequently asked

Which OSRS TCG cards are linked to Misthalin Mystery?
3 catalogue cards map to Misthalin Mystery: Bucket, Tinderbox and Knife. They are the quest's items and the monsters you fight that exist as cards in the Old School RuneScape TCG. The mapping is maintained by OSRS Card Exchange; whether something is a card, and its rarity, come from the OSRS TCG catalogue.
Is Misthalin Mystery members only?
No, Misthalin Mystery is free-to-play. It is rated Novice.
What is the rarest card from Misthalin Mystery?
Bucket at Common, which packs land on about 37.34% of the time. Rarity comes from the card's OSRS TCG score, not from the quest.
How do I get the OSRS TCG Misthalin Mystery cards?
Pull them from packs in the OSRS TCG RuneLite plugin, or trade for them. Open exchanges for this quest's cards are listed further down this page, and the trade itself happens in the plugin's own Trade window in game.
Does this page tell me how to complete Misthalin Mystery?
It gives a brief walkthrough overview and maps the quest to its OSRS TCG cards — the items and monsters involved, and who is trading them. For the complete requirements, detailed steps and rewards, the OSRS Wiki link on this page is the authority.

Related cards

Cards that come up around Misthalin Mystery but that you don't actually need for it — NPCs mentioned in passing, scenery, or items suggested only for convenience.